The Ballad of Wallis Island * A Unique Film With Wonderful Acting, An Unconventional Story, And Heartfelt Themes
Wednesday, March 26th, 2025The Ballad Of Wallis Island follows Charles (Tim Key), an eccentric lottery winner who lives alone on a remote island and dreams of getting his favorite musicians, McGwyer Mortimer (Tom Basden & Carey Mulligan) back together. His fantasy turns into reality when the bandmates and former lovers accept his invitation to play a private show at his home on Wallis Island. Old tensions resurface as Charles tries desperately to salvage his dream gig.
KIDS FIRST! Film Critic Daniel S. comments, “The Ballad of Wallis Island is a unique film that I absolutely loved. Its wonderful performances, unconventional story, and heartfelt themes make The Ballad of Wallis Island a stellar drama.” See his full review below.
The Ballad of Wallis Island
By Daniel Salem, KIDS FIRST! Film Critic, age 17

Carey Mulligan as Nell Mortimer and Tom Basden as Herb McGwyer in THE BALLAD OF WALLIS ISLAND, Focus Features. Credit: Alistair Heap/Focus Features ©2025 All Rights Reserved
The Ballad of Wallis Island is a unique film that I absolutely loved. Its wonderful performances, unconventional story, and heartfelt themes make The Ballad of Wallis Island a stellar drama.
The Ballad of Wallis Island follows the famed singer and songwriter Herb McGwyer (Tom Basden) as he travels to a secluded island for a gig. Hired to perform for two-time lottery winner Charles (Tim Key), Herb is forced not only to put on a good show, but to find himself emotionally, musically, and spiritually along the way.
The performances in The Ballad of Wallis Island are nothing short of spectacular. Although Tom Basden’s Herb McGwyer leads the film, he shares the screen with Tim Key’s Charles, and the two are incredible together. They have a sort of chemistry that feels natural, and watching their friendship blossom throughout the film is a joy. They are polar opposites that are bound together, forced to find common ground. It’s no wonder the two work so well on screen together because they actually wrote the film together!

(L to R) Co-writer/actor Tom Basden, director James Griffiths and actor Carey Mulligan on the set of THE BALLAD OF WALLIS ISLAND, a Focus Features release. Credit: Alistair Heap/Focus Features ©2025 All Rights Reserved
To begin with, Tom Basden’s acting excellently captures the kind of existential crisis of an artist past their prime. Although not uncommon, this theme is a central part of the film. Herb McGwyer has descended from his peak in popularity, and Basden depicts his entrapment in the past so well. Tim Key’s portrayal of Charles is 100% the highlight of the film. He brings a kind and bright energy every time he is on screen, which works perfectly to counteract the gloomy Herb. All of Key’s comedic lines are well-delivered, and his witty, but lighthearted demeanor uplifts the film. Both Basden and Key experience an emotional arc together that is beautiful to watch. Academy Award nominee Carrey Mulligan not only produces, but stars in this film as well. Mulligan plays Nell Mortimer, the other half of “McGwyer Mortimer,” an incredibly popular music duo. Her portrayal as a former musician is outstanding and starkly contrasts with Herb’s personality. Their onscreen dynamic is great, as is their chemistry. They are past lovers, and watching them reunite after years, and dissect the band’s falling out is very interesting.
The Ballad of Wallis Island is rather unusual in that it takes place in one location – an island in the middle of nowhere. Wallis Island is tucked away from the rest of society, and therefore cut off from wifi, technology, and civilization. It feels as though Wallis Island has its own personality in its transformative nature. It morphs the characters emotionally, and puts them to the test. Both Herb and Nell are trapped and pushed to figure out what they want. Are they truly just seeking payment for the gig, or are they looking for something deeper, like a connection?

Tom Basden as Herb McGwyer, Carey Mulligan as Nell Mortimer and Tim Key as Charles in THE BALLAD OF WALLIS ISLAND Credit: Courtesy of Focus Features © 2025 All Rights Reserved.
The Ballad of Wallis Island juggles several mature themes, including societal isolation and the cost of fame, but the film’s message is about the importance of human relationships. We find Herb kind of disappointed with himself, and discouraged, but only until he goes to Wallis Island does he begin to find meaning in his life. Through his friendship with Charles, a man with whom he is completely different, he finds what is missing in his life and art – human connection and companionship. Ironically, his adventure to a place secluded from all society is where he learns the power of the bonds and friendships he builds.
I give The Ballad of Wallis Island 4 out of 5 stars, and recommend it for ages 12 to 18, plus adults. The Ballad of Wallis Island releases exclusively in theaters March 28, 2025.